mine are probably melted chocolate, tootsie rolls, nuttela, and peanut butter. Any other baits that work well?

If you sealed the structure, they’ll get hungry and eat anything.

PB is what we use unless there’s an allergic issue we’re told about. Eventually you’ll leave your bait at the last house or run out when you didn’t expect to. Easy to find at any convenience store is a prime concern for any bait.

Peanut butter is hard to beat....

I have used bacon grease. Not in the summer or it melts.

Just started getting after them, I use peanut butter also.

Chunky peanut butter.

Tootsie rolls, get the soft and push them in the pan then add a few sunflower seed to the mix. Just a few seeds. JMO

Small chunk of Fig Newton. For me, nothing else even close.

peanut butter with black sunflower seed mixed in