Coop:
I have experimented with fresh from the bladder urine, ordinary pen urine, light color, dark color and real aged urine and I could never isolate one iota of difference. I think for an animal to be that fussy they would had to have a bad experience with a certain odor to avoid it or not respond to there own nature. Whats important to me is that the urine be clean, collected in the Winter months and strained of food particles so it doesn't smell or turn putrid. A well processed urine by a reputable supplier will remain effective for years if stored in glass in a cool dark place.
Ace