Land Trapping Archive


Home ~ Mission Statement ~ Trap Talk ~ ADC Forum ~ Trap Shed ~ Trap Chat
Trapper Tips ~ Links ~ Gallery ~ Basic Sets ~ Convention Calendar ~ Trapper's Humor
Fur Buyers Directory ~ Trapper's Tales ~ Words From The Past ~ Legends ~ Archives
~Catalog~

Page 2 of 3 <123>
Topic Options
#439702 - 12/01/07 06:23 PM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: Andy S]
pass-thru Online   content
trapper


Registered: 12/23/06
Posts: 706
Loc: Hubert NC 33
Thank you gentleman, for the informative discussion.
Top
#439766 - 12/01/07 06:56 PM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: pass-thru]
Asa Lenon Offline
trapper


Registered: 12/23/06
Posts: 2476
Loc: Gulliver, Michigan
Doesn't anyone, even the pros in this thread have any comments on what my Dad had to say about the relationship between set visibility and large backings?????????????????Ace
Top
#440075 - 12/01/07 09:34 PM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: Asa Lenon]
CharlesKS Offline
trapper


Registered: 12/23/06
Posts: 7035
Loc: Kansas,31,6-1,220,B/B NS
 Originally Posted By: Asa Lenon
Doesn't anyone, even the pros in this thread have any comments on what my Dad had to say about the relationship between set visibility and large backings?????????????????Ace


if i respond to this, are you going to call me a fool to becasue i have a different experiance?

if i set all my sets in the open, like allready said, theyd get run over, seen by deer hunters, etc. i cant see evidence of coyotes not wanting to work a set if they cant see 30 feetin every direction.

i just cant help but think alot of GRAET set locations would be passed by. In an effort to save TIME, which is important to me and many others, i just cant spend 10 minutes walking around trying to find the PERFECT spot that fits all the criteria your dad described. I KNOW im not catching every single coyote. I dont NEED to, im fur trapping, as a hobby. I also dont quite believe i can catch EVERY SINGLE ONE. ive had places ive pulled 15 coyyotes of a small bit of cover or whatever, go back 3 weeks later to cat trap, and theres new tracks.
_________________________
without farm subsidies, you box of cornflakes will cost you 15$


Top
#440198 - 12/01/07 10:29 PM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: CharlesKS]
k9. Offline
trapper


Registered: 12/23/06
Posts: 3192
Loc: Brooklyn, Iowa 45 years old st...
"Now why in blank would coyotes always accept sets out in the open and more often not commit to sets with large backings when the same lures were used over and over and over in years of testing? Please tell me how lures could possibly come into play here? You know as well as myself and every intelligent trapper on here can clearly see you sent up a combination smoke screen, twisted the subject and managed to get in a blow below the belt all at the same time. Very skillful I must say but not what one might expect from an officer of the law. I have even had trappers e-mail me sharing the same setiments about your questioable character. Ace"

Wow you are really giving me credit for being far more intelligent than I am, as far as this smoke screen, twisting the subject, below the belt stuff goes.

It is interesting to me that Charles can comment on your lure ingrediants making for a "wary" response and nothing happens. However when I comment on it, and qualify it by saying I donot believe it to be the case, and some deep seated conspiracy exists to somehow damage you.

The point is really not about your lures at all, which I imagine ARE OF EXCELLENT QUALITY. The point is you contradict yourself when you face a common sense response to your wary coyote theory, when you start comparing a coyote naturally chasing or hunting a rabbit in such an environment, but becoming wary at unnatural lure smells. I'm sorry it's a contradiction, it's your contradiction not mine.

I am glad you are getting warm hugs via email to make you feel better. I am not out to make you feel bad, but you do not seem equipped to handle any scrutiny.

Your quesiton to me about coyotes accepting sets in the open, compared to up against cover, high banks, or whatever is easy for me to reply to. I know other trappers personally, and have also read or seen videos by other trappers who I do not know personally, who are with a great degree of consistency catching coyotes contrary to your information. Not only in the past, but they are doing it NOW. Some of these guys are some of the best coyote trappers around. I am not as good a coyote trapper as some of those guys, but I myself have gone out and proven to myself that these are acceptable set locations.

Your advice runs contrary to those peoples experience. That does not make you a bad person. When I assess the information, I wonder what the difference is, and also what the consistency is in each scenario. To me a coyote is a coyote, so the behavior should be consistent nationwide. I know we disagree on this, but I am talking about how I draw MY conclusions, not yours.

I know that a high bank is a high bank, and high cover is high cover, whether it is in Iowa, Kansas, or Michigan. So that is consisent nationwide.

I know that numbers of successful trappers consistently catch coyotes against or by such cover. The only trapper I personally hear talking contrary to this has been you.

I read your father's information. I am being careful here because I have no doubt that your father was a fine man, worthy of a LOT of respect. I am also sure that his teachings and writings had a lot of influence on you.

So I have one guy saying he feels coyotes get wary approaching areas of high cover, and I see lots of others who successfully prove that theory wrong.

I am left to conclude that the observer (YOU) had preconcieved ideas about what should happen and has become close minded to anything else.

You give lot's of advice and I am not saying people should not take it. I am saying that all options should be considered in a common sense way by each trapper and carried on his or her line with them, to use how they see fit. People should look at both extremes in an issue, then find some middle ground that suits them.

You have a lot of trappers on here with varying experience, some much better coyote trappers than me. You just can't make blanket statements about coyote behavior without getting the flipside of the issue represented.
_________________________
2008
One coon
One skunk


Top
#440232 - 12/01/07 10:51 PM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: Andy S]
k9. Offline
trapper


Registered: 12/23/06
Posts: 3192
Loc: Brooklyn, Iowa 45 years old st...
Also Asa have your email warm fuzzies look at my first post. I was responding with my beliefs and directing nothing at you. I only directed comments to you when you started quoting me. I am sorry you are personalizing my every comment. I would suggest if you cannot handle such debate you just stop trying to engage me in such discussions. I do not follow the "Thou Shalt not question Asa" part of the rules. The thing is, some of the things you are putting out there should be questioned if you are saying it is the ONLY way.

I have nothing to sell. My motivation is only worthwhile coyote discussion and information.
_________________________
2008
One coon
One skunk


Top
#440247 - 12/01/07 11:07 PM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: k9.]
yotes4ever Offline
trapper


Registered: 12/25/06
Posts: 22
Loc: rockwood, mi.
I think if nothing else if a fox or coyote can see the set from more directions I would want low backing.I wouldnt want them to walk right by on the wrong side and never know it was there
Top
#440414 - 12/02/07 07:39 AM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: yotes4ever]
Asa Lenon Offline
trapper


Registered: 12/23/06
Posts: 2476
Loc: Gulliver, Michigan
Thanks for a straight forward comment yotes4ever, I agree that your comment is common sense. Straight forward, honest comments sure beat long winded, twisted pages of diatribe. Ace
Top
#440436 - 12/02/07 08:02 AM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: yotes4ever]
Jonathan Online   content
trapper


Registered: 12/23/06
Posts: 1814
Loc: Northwestern New York
When trap placement and "visibility" factors in relationship to the set location for canines are discussed, there is one common denominator generated in the opinion gardens: Each trapper has determined what works for them in their respective geography. And, that is based on their respective experience through training, observation and adaptation for the best methods to harvest canines where they trap. Nothing more.

There is a wide distribution of canines across this continent. Each species has managed to adapt itself to an immense diversity of habitat and topography - from deserts to mountains. That in itself is impressive when all things are considered. And, the trapping effort simply corresponds to the habits and behaviors of those respective territories and the animal's life cycle.

The difference between the differences are spelled in the comments solicited. I am not aware of a trapping "bible" - old, or new testament, that has only one interpretation of the "word" on how to trap canines. There are different recipes on how to do things for everything on the planet - this one included. Interestingly enough, the results are basically the same no matter how the cooks "work" in their own kitchens!

Topics of this nature are valuable and worthy of discussion to demonstrate what works for individuals in different parts of the country, but they are not worth bickering over. What is where you are, just is. The options donated through those opinions can be digested and tried by those who are new or inexperienced at canine trapping to experiment from those classroom notes and applying them to their circumstances.

Jonathan

Top
#440460 - 12/02/07 08:20 AM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: Jonathan]
Asa Lenon Offline
trapper


Registered: 12/23/06
Posts: 2476
Loc: Gulliver, Michigan
Now Jonathan, you know I respect you and your opinions but all aspects and factors of trapping techniques do not change with geographical locations. For example, set location, set visibility and eye appeal and utilizing the prevailing wind direction to one's advantage are universal. As my Dad pointed out in the excerpt I copied and pasted from one of his booklets, even if placing a set up againse a large obstruction of view had no bearing on the outcome of the set for that reason the large backing/obstruction would still obstruct good set visibility and whatever eye appeal one may be able to add to the set. In the long run this would diminish one's total harvest. That is just commons universal sense in my opinion!
Thank you for your input Jonathan! Ace

Top
#440513 - 12/02/07 09:11 AM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: Asa Lenon]
trapper72 Offline
trapper


Registered: 12/22/06
Posts: 1367
Loc: Massena NY
Thanks to all for the comments, I plan on trapping coyotes soon, a first for me.

Asa, I know what your getting at, take everything a location has to offer and work it towards your advantage, working around a few BASIC guidelines.
_________________________
~Another sig that had served it's purpose~

Top
#440517 - 12/02/07 09:13 AM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: Asa Lenon]
Jonathan Online   content
trapper


Registered: 12/23/06
Posts: 1814
Loc: Northwestern New York
Asa, There is a subtle, parallel analogy here in relationship to "universal" in this dialog. For example, you and I were brought up to make red fox sets, without being over anal, to be what many refer to as clean freaks. The northern Midwest regions we trained in, that set site precaution was imperative. There is no way that I could get by with less where I trap compared to the success of those who do not have to bother with this precaution in different parts of the country.

I would not begin to engage in such a debate over human scent consciousness, because I have no capacity to process those regional differences in animal behavior. All that I know is that I have to be especially extra conscious of it in my methods.

Through some quirk of animal evolution, geography, and behavioral adaptation to their living/hunting habitats regionally, it seems like there would be differences in the "visibility" thesis that you espouse.

I really cannot debate this with you, or anyone else, because all of my red fox sets are in the "open" as your canine sets. The only exception in my experience is in making a dirt hole set right in the middle of a thick hedgerow for gray fox. I am not a coyote trapper, so I cannot relate to that aspect of canine trapping.

And, friend, I honor and respect all of your opinions - few of which I have occasion to disagree with. And, this is not one of them because we do it the same way. My comments were digested and keyed to the accounts from those who presented divergent philosophies and practices by comparison based on their respective regions - a personal interpretation from the experiences they presented.

Jonathan

Top
#440641 - 12/02/07 10:34 AM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: Andy S]
ZekeMan Offline
trapper


Registered: 04/19/07
Posts: 652
Loc: NW Pennsylvania
I was enjoying this post until it turned into a verbal war of insults and name calling. I am observing ALL information. I have only caught one coyote my whole life. I would love to catch a bunch more. I am surprised at some of the outbursts from people who I've read about in trapping magazines since I was a little kid. These are ones who I've considered to be trapping idols of mine. I am not sure what to think about all of this. C'mon guys,if you must direct an insult at someone, do it in a pm. There are young trappers on here who who idolize many of you, and to see these negative remarks will be a huge dissappointment to them. Hope this doesn't offend. Just a fan who is surprised and dissappointed.

Edited by ZekeMan (12/02/07 10:53 AM)
_________________________



Top
#440669 - 12/02/07 10:49 AM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: Asa Lenon]
Nick C Online   shocked
trapper


Registered: 12/22/06
Posts: 6544
Loc: Iowa 21 YEARS OLD
 Originally Posted By: Asa Lenon
When possible it is best to keep coyote and red fox set out away, say 25 feet or so from backings that obstruct their view from looking around in every direction before lowering their guard to investigate the set and lure.


 Originally Posted By: Asa Lenon
However, with all due respect I don't see any obstructions to view in any one of the pictures, all I see is normal every day set locations, most are set with common sense right in the edge of a field with good visibility in every direction. Ace


I need some clarification.

In Charles's Pictures and most of Gary's PIctures. It's obvious they can't see in every direction for 25-30 feet.

Then you agreed that those are indeed good, every day locations.

What exactly is an obstruction of view, in your opinion, if those don't count?

Honestly?

Please do not copy and paste an excerpt from your Dad's writings. I want to know what you think, as I'm confused, and need some clarification.
_________________________
I BLESS THE RAINS DOWN IN AFRICA!!!

Top
#440688 - 12/02/07 11:01 AM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: Nick C]
trapper72 Offline
trapper


Registered: 12/22/06
Posts: 1367
Loc: Massena NY
 Quote:
What exactly is an obstruction of view


A brick wall three feet high twenty feet long.

I believe what Asa is talking about as obstructed view is a downed tree three feet in diameter in the middle or edge of an opening, I dramatic rise or hump in the ground something like a dump truck load of spoils on a hedge row.
_________________________
~Another sig that had served it's purpose~

Top
#440723 - 12/02/07 11:26 AM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: trapper72]
Asa Lenon Offline
trapper


Registered: 12/23/06
Posts: 2476
Loc: Gulliver, Michigan
If you are referring to me, Sorry ZekeMan, It would be nice if I could ever be allowed to comment on any aspect of trapping without getting a negative response from the same few people. I've been on this forum for 8 or 9 years and there is at least one memeber that has disagreed with every single piece of advice from my experiences I can think of that I ever offered to help a novice trapper. Even a peace loving fellow like me can be driven to the breaking point and have it up to the ears. Many times I have spent a half hour or more thinking and typing of ways to help a trapper with his question and make it understandable only to instantly have the whole thread diverted to defending myself and the subject being completely twisted from it origin. Sometimes those negative answers may have be justified as I may have been misunderstood for not making my point clearly enough. However, most instances are simple diatribe and harassment. My apologies ZekeMan and others who feel the same way, I should know better than to reply at all to certain personalities and let the trappers simply weigh it out in the balance even if they are novive trappers being confused by it all. Ace
Top
#440732 - 12/02/07 11:37 AM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: Asa Lenon]
Aaron Proffitt Offline
trapper


Registered: 10/14/07
Posts: 249
Loc: El Reno,Oklahoma
 Originally Posted By: Asa Lenon
If you are referring to me, Sorry ZekeMan, It would be nice if I could ever be allowed to comment on any aspect of trapping without getting a negative response from the same few people. I've been on this forum for 8 or 9 years and there is at least one memeber that has disagreed with every single piece of advice from my experiences I can think of that I ever offered to help a novice trapper. Even a peace loving fellow like me can be driven to the breaking point and have it up to the ears. Many times I have spent a half hour or more thinking and typing of ways to help a trapper with his question and make it understandable only to instantly have the whole thread diverted to defending myself and the subject being completely twisted from it origin. Sometimes those negative answers may have be justified as I may have been misunderstood for not making my point clearly enough. However, most instances are simple diatribe and harassment. My apologies ZekeMan and others who feel the same way, I should know better than to reply at all to certain personalities and let the trappers simply weigh it out in the balance even if they are novive trappers being confused by it all. Ace


It doesn't always have to be about you,ya know. ;)I've been following this thread and I thought things were civil.
In any case,think maye your taking it a 'lil personal.
_________________________
Season totals
coyotes-14
coon-3
If fruitarians eat fruit and vegetarians eat vegetables...what do humanitarians eat ?

Top
#440755 - 12/02/07 11:58 AM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: Aaron Proffitt]
Gary Online   confused
trapper


Registered: 01/08/07
Posts: 8405
Loc: Indiana
asa no disrespect for you and ya dad's methods .... but i read that you must be out in the open to catch canines, and set only on level ground for many years growing up ... this lead me to go out of my way and pass up great set locations cuzz EVERYTHING wasnt textbook perfect ... i pass on what i have learned so the young people wont make the same mistakes i did .... im not saying you are wrong and the few of us that agree that canines can be caught in thicker stuff are right .... just that it works for me ..... sum of these pix arent the best .... but here are a couple yotes IN the corn ... remake ... IN the corn .... not at the edge .... red in a narrow spot in high weeds red next to a HUGE uprooted tree ... ya can see part of a root on the lefthand side ... no way he was seein over it red in a grown up field setting in a narrow strip between two HIGH brush/corn area
_________________________

Top
#440756 - 12/02/07 11:58 AM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: Aaron Proffitt]
ZekeMan Offline
trapper


Registered: 04/19/07
Posts: 652
Loc: NW Pennsylvania
Asa........ I will still value your input, as I always have. I just was surprized a little. I know a lot of young people who look up to you as a trapper. As an adult, I can understand being pushed to a breaking point. Some of the younger people who idolize you may not understand. I have faced the same junk from users before. As you said, it always seems to be the same few. I sincerely apologize if you were offended or hurt it any way by my response. That wasn't my intentions. Just trying to look out for the young trappers who don't have the life experience to rationalize that type of situation on their own. I look forward to reading your posts, because I need all the help I can get! LOL!
_________________________



Top
#440765 - 12/02/07 12:08 PM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: Gary]
Aaron Proffitt Offline
trapper


Registered: 10/14/07
Posts: 249
Loc: El Reno,Oklahoma
 Originally Posted By: Gary
... this lead me to go out of my way and pass up great set locations cuzz EVERYTHING wasnt textbook perfect


EXACTLY !! Very well said ,Gary.
I used to have alot of those old trapping books when I was a kid and tried to follow 'em to the letter.And it was frustrating.Only when I began to add a little salt to my reads did things really turn productive.
Hard gained experience trumps the theoretical everytime.
_________________________
Season totals
coyotes-14
coon-3
If fruitarians eat fruit and vegetarians eat vegetables...what do humanitarians eat ?

Top
#440783 - 12/02/07 12:17 PM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: ZekeMan]
Asa Lenon Offline
trapper


Registered: 12/23/06
Posts: 2476
Loc: Gulliver, Michigan
Zeke Man: Thank you for your reply.

Gary: No one ever said one couldn't catch coyotes with sets made up against large backings that obstruct viewing. What I'm saying and my Dad was saying in his tips booklet is that given a choice I would choose the open spot for the possibly wary canines that are too jittery to lower their heads unless they can see around clearly in every direction for 25-30 feet or so. As my Dad pointed out, keeping sets out in the open has two other advantages also, offering better set visibility and eye appeal should the prevailing wind direction be blowing the lure's odor in the opposite direction of the anticipated approach of the animal and also that if a wary canine does its cautious sniffing back aways from a set they can see clearly from back 25-30 feet they are less apt to detect any possible adverse trap odor and dig at it or avoid stepping on it. These are just small details Gary, but as I always say "its the small details that add up to maximum numbers one by one by one". Of course one is going to make connections as long as there are animals there in the vicinity to trap, sets are made and positioned properly, lures are used appropriately, etc. Everything else about adding numbers relies in application of the lesser details. Think about it Gary, there has to be a reason why some trappers are always and consistently more successful than other trappers in their region. One reason could be they work harder at it and the other is the methodical usage and application of small factors/details incorporated into their trapping routine. Ace

PS-Here is a copy and paste from my first post in this thread that was personally attacked, does anyone see anything in my reply that should spark personal negative replies or anything in the advice that would be detrimental to a trapper's success whatever geographical location they may trap in?

Good advice from stevenr. When possible it is best to keep coyote and red fox set out away, say 25 feet or so from backings that obstruct their view from looking around in every direction before lowering their guard to investigate the set and lure. As stevenr stated, a smaller backing like a hump, rock, etc they can see over keeps the canine from possibly investigating from the backside. I have seen trappers who were trapping tight to large obstructions and catching nothing go to regular harvesting by moving their sets out a few feet into the open and adhering to this simple rule. Obstructions to veiwing do not seem to affect grey fox the same way from my limited experience with the grey fox, having moved into my region in recent years. Ace

Please note that I stated "When possible" it is the best policy. That is my opinion from my own personal experiences and I reaffirm that opinion. Of cours I've broken that rule of my own, circumstances change anything once in a while. I've made hundreds of sets at embankments and other large backings if it was my only choice and caught hundreds of animal doing so. However, that does not alter the fact that a good proven policy isn't a good policy. Given a choice, for example I can't imagine one making a set in the middle of a thicket so thick it could hardly be trampled through if there was an open spot 25 feet away. That is all i'm saying Gary and others. Good trapping! Ace


Edited by Asa Lenon (12/02/07 12:38 PM)

Top
#440785 - 12/02/07 12:18 PM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: ZekeMan]
inline50 Offline
trapper


Registered: 12/25/06
Posts: 1144
Loc: carroll county, IL.
we all need to stick together, or we fall apart. Whether it's asa,charles, paul, gary,k9 nick,jim,bob,larry, ext. TAKE IN THERE ADVISE ,try there methods and see whitch one works for you. Heck even try some new methods,if it works then you to can be giving advise on here. I've learned a lot on here.even though I'm 42 years old and trapped since i was 10 , not a pro by all means but i have a ball doing so. Now i have kids and a nephew that love to go on the line with us and they have a ball also.So i guess we are doing something right. We might not catch the big no#'s that some do but we still enjoy it.
LETS ALL GET TOGETHER AND HAVE A BIG OL' PARTY!!!!!!
TIM
_________________________
take a child hunting,fishing,or trapping today and you won't have to hunt the streets for them tomorrow!!!!!

Top
#440823 - 12/02/07 12:50 PM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: inline50]
Gary Online   confused
trapper


Registered: 01/08/07
Posts: 8405
Loc: Indiana
i agree ASA .... hard work has alot to do with it ...add to that a knowledge of the animals the person is targeting .... the amount of quality sets out in areas where there are target species .... knowing what to do if there are problem animals....learning to adapt to different situations ... and tryin new methods .... a good trapper is one that goes out and does the work, knows the animals, and puts in quality sets .... a great trapper is the one that does the above but THINKS and adjusts/experiments ..... i have learned a bunch over the years and one thing that i have learned is ... there are no set rules when trapping .... i try to encourage the young people that are just startin out .... but i dont tell them how to trap .... only tell them the ways that i have made catches .... if they ask me if a certain type set will work ... or i think a certain location will pay off .... i simply tell them that they should try it and see how it goes .... who am i to tell them that it wont work ... when i know that it very well may be the best set/location that is there where they are at .... no place is the same ...like we typed earlier .... what may work here, in KS, in IA, or MI may not work as good elsewhere .... i do believe that yotes do work sets more aggressive in high populated areas ... these yotes have to be more aggressive or they wouldnt make it so well .... i also believe that yotes are animal of habit and what one yote will do others will also to some degree .... there are always gonna be those that will do things a bit differently ... just like people they all have different personalities
_________________________

Top
#440830 - 12/02/07 12:52 PM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: Aaron Proffitt]
Jonathan Online   content
trapper


Registered: 12/23/06
Posts: 1814
Loc: Northwestern New York
It is a delight to see conflict resolution evolve with mature exchanges of chalk on this blackboard.

An individual's functional opinion, whether earned, or learned, from days or years of experience, need not be agreed with; however, the owner of that opinion does not deserve to have his/her personal human integrity attacked with verbal toxicity after making a civilized, instructional comment.

I can empathize with Asa and others who have been on the receiving end of this verbal abuse. They are allowed to snap in defense of their own dignity and time taken to teach from a heartfelt lesson plan.

Gary's dichotomy showing limited visibility at a set site photographically by comparison to those proponents of the more open visibility set site (myself included,) perfectly illustrates that it can be done both ways when you know what you are doing if trapping in the desert, farmland or mountains.

With that said, after 55 years of setting in the open, I am still learning and definitely will try moving into the lower visibility zones to see how well I can do in that corridor.

A thank you and round of applause to those of you experienced men who have made significant contributions to the managed differences of opinion filleted out here on this topic. It has been very educational for me to watch, look and listen during this bout before the bell rings.

Regards,

Jonathan

Top
#441040 - 12/02/07 04:06 PM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: Jonathan]
k9. Offline
trapper


Registered: 12/23/06
Posts: 3192
Loc: Brooklyn, Iowa 45 years old st...
You nailed it inline. Take all the info and see what works for you. Ideas and methods evolve over time, and improvement is just a natural thing.

Jonathan I enjoy your information, but to term my discussion with Asa as "verbal abuse" I think is a little short sighted for a thinker such as yourself. Asa and I have been disagreeing, yes, but I have not been verbally abusing him. Perhaps I am too callous to identify it when I see it. I am very capable of it, but I respect Paul's forum too much to do so to anyone.

I will be the first to say that I think people should take Asa's fathers methods, and give them a try. I have no doubt such trappers would be successful. However, no young or beginner trapper should conclude that there is only "one" way of doing things. Such short sightedness will surely handicap any trapper who wants to be serious about coyote trapping.

Nice pictures Gary.

I am headed to the fur buyers with a load of coyotes and coons. Will check in here later.

I find it interesting that I am percieved as always disagreeing, etc when one of these threads starts. Nothing could be further from the truth, and I hold no personal grudges out of the deal. Both sides of any discussion need to come to the table prepared for give and take. If they are not mentally prepared for reasonable debate, they should stay away from the table.

Sometimes in life we just have to agree to disagree. I am always willing to do so, quite frankly it means far more to others than it does to me. However, rather than just let it end in disagreement, little swipes keep being taken without naming me, and quite frankly that cheapens the debate.

That's too bad, cause there is a lot that can be learned by me, and other people reading in when people with coyotes hanging in the shed get to debating.
_________________________
2008
One coon
One skunk


Top
#443150 - 12/03/07 08:38 PM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: k9.]
Littlbigd Offline
trapper


Registered: 06/12/07
Posts: 142
Loc: Anchorage, AK
As another beginner I have to say this is one of the best and most educational threads that I have read here in a long time!

A good educational debate only helps everyone here learn. If anyone got a bit 'miffed' during this thread please remember that you still did the rest of us a HUGE favor by explaining and justifying your reasoning.

I'm saving this thread in my personal notes! Thanks guys!
_________________________
Life Member: National Rifle Assoc (NRA), National Trappers Assoc (NTA)
Member: American Gamefowl Society (AGFS)

Top
#443302 - 12/03/07 09:46 PM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: Littlbigd]
Orlando Offline
trapper


Registered: 10/26/07
Posts: 49
Loc: North Central Kansas
This seems kind of like the old debate of "Great Taste" vs "Less Filling."
As one who made his first dirt hole set ever, just two weeks ago, I have been gleaning all the info possible from this web site. My son and I have caught 7 yotes to date with 6 sets using information from this site. I think this site is invaluable for a beginning trapper. I don't know who's right in this discussion. Probably both. I just know I'm going to sit on the sidelines and learn something that will help me get that 8th yote!
Thanks!
_________________________
Nature is reckless of the individual. Aldo Leupold.

Yotes 12
Coons 15
Cats 1
Beaver 3
Grinners 21
Pack Rat 1

Top
#443310 - 12/03/07 09:58 PM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: Littlbigd]
Drifter Offline
trapper


Registered: 12/22/06
Posts: 1299
Loc: Stronghurst , IL
Sometimes the chaff is hard to glean away when tempers get to flarring .

One thing I have found over the years to hold true is " Let the animals tell you " Differing populations as well as areas will all be part of the equation . To be successful at trapping any species one must pay the price of trying and failing . True that information gathered ahead can shorten the learnning curve but not make one a pro on the first time out .

Lure and bait being one variable that has never been used with the same result even in the same type sets by 2 differant trappers in the same area . I still puzzle over that one . My wife uses a mild lure with good results . I can't catch diddly with it . I use a louder lure and have good results but it doesn't work for her .

Drifter
_________________________
Light travels faster than sound. This is why some people appear bright
until you hear them speak.

Top
#443376 - 12/03/07 10:51 PM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: Drifter]
Calvin Offline
trapper


Registered: 09/12/07
Posts: 958
Loc: Farminton, Minnesota
Thank you Asa for the input on backings. I am no pro and was wondering more about it a few weeks ago and how it effected or may effect responses and why. You cleared this up for me and I will be adjusting my sets abit next year in hopes of an improved response. I don't have high coyote populations here so it may make a difference. I also understand the concerns from those who trap in farm country as tractors main purpose seems to be to hunt down your canine traps and squish the guts out of them. Sometimes you can not set out away from backing...BUT sometimes I do have that option and I will modify my approach abit now.

I (like many, surly) enjoy your posts and what your dad has written in the past. Many of us read them word for word and learn from them. Sometimes you may just be defending yourself but we still benefit from it, regardless. Be assured, it doesnt take much ability to figure out who on here is the real deal and the others who just like tooting their horn.

It doesn't seem to matter what you post here as someone will surely attempt to disprove your findings not matter what, or how minor, the observation is.
_________________________
Any day above ground is a good day.

Top
#443391 - 12/03/07 11:06 PM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: Calvin]
k9. Offline
trapper


Registered: 12/23/06
Posts: 3192
Loc: Brooklyn, Iowa 45 years old st...
"Sometimes you may just be defending yourself but we still benefit from it, regardless. Be assured, it doesnt take much ability to figure out who on here is the real deal and the others who just like tooting their horn.

It doesn't seem to matter what you post here as someone will surely attempt to disprove your findings not matter what, or how minor, the observation is. "

Wow Calvin...that's a deep observation.
_________________________
2008
One coon
One skunk


Top
#443393 - 12/03/07 11:08 PM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: k9.]
Gary Online   confused
trapper


Registered: 01/08/07
Posts: 8405
Loc: Indiana
lol .... k9 why are ya respondin ?? YOU KNOW NUTHIN !!! ;\) \:\)
_________________________

Top
#443396 - 12/03/07 11:11 PM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: Gary]
k9. Offline
trapper


Registered: 12/23/06
Posts: 3192
Loc: Brooklyn, Iowa 45 years old st...
Just got in from scraping some coon. All my sets have about an inch of ice on them and I'm about to go nuts. Not remaking anything as we have another front coming in, then will hit the sets with some dirt.

I don't claim to know much, but that conversation with photos attached was a heck of a lot deeper than horn tootin is.
_________________________
2008
One coon
One skunk


Top
#443399 - 12/03/07 11:13 PM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: k9.]
Nick C Online   shocked
trapper


Registered: 12/22/06
Posts: 6544
Loc: Iowa 21 YEARS OLD
It would be INTERESTING to see the NUMBER of coyotes killed by the guys who are in the "know" in this thread in the past 10 or 15 years.

REALLY INTERESTING ???
_________________________
I BLESS THE RAINS DOWN IN AFRICA!!!

Top
#443400 - 12/03/07 11:14 PM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: k9.]
Gary Online   confused
trapper


Registered: 01/08/07
Posts: 8405
Loc: Indiana
those animals were relocated to take the pix ... ask charles and nick ... lmao
_________________________

Top
#443409 - 12/03/07 11:22 PM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: Gary]
k9. Offline
trapper


Registered: 12/23/06
Posts: 3192
Loc: Brooklyn, Iowa 45 years old st...
They were nice pics Gary. I have always wanted to do the Children of the Corn thing but always have stayed on the edge. OUr coon, coyotes and fox just sleep right out there between the rows, and don't come out until the field gets harvested. Lots of rabbits and food in there, great cover, no reason to leave.

When we have late standing corn it always throws my catch off, until it gets picked then BOOM everything starts to click that I have set in the area.
_________________________
2008
One coon
One skunk


Top
#443410 - 12/03/07 11:24 PM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: k9.]
Nick C Online   shocked
trapper


Registered: 12/22/06
Posts: 6544
Loc: Iowa 21 YEARS OLD
 Originally Posted By: k9.
OUr coon, coyotes and fox just sleep right out there between the rows, and don't come out until the field gets harvested. Lots of rabbits and food in there, great cover, no reason to leave.



So true!!

Combining corn this fall, I would kick up rabbit after rabbit each round (Not the same ones either, \:\) ) also tons of pheasants. Corn fields animals livlihoods in these parts. Especially the areas of Iowa that are treeless!
_________________________
I BLESS THE RAINS DOWN IN AFRICA!!!

Top
#443416 - 12/03/07 11:30 PM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: Nick C]
Gary Online   confused
trapper


Registered: 01/08/07
Posts: 8405
Loc: Indiana
have ya ever went callin for canines on standin corn ?? if so ....where do MOST come from when hittin the calls ??
_________________________

Top
#443420 - 12/03/07 11:32 PM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: Gary]
Nick C Online   shocked
trapper


Registered: 12/22/06
Posts: 6544
Loc: Iowa 21 YEARS OLD
I have a little bit. Only 2 coyotes I can think of though. Just randomly busted outta the corn field, loping to the call.
_________________________
I BLESS THE RAINS DOWN IN AFRICA!!!

Top
#443421 - 12/03/07 11:32 PM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: Gary]
k9. Offline
trapper


Registered: 12/23/06
Posts: 3192
Loc: Brooklyn, Iowa 45 years old st...
No I have not, but I am betting they come from the corn, that would be my prediction unless it was contrary to windage.
_________________________
2008
One coon
One skunk


Top
#443425 - 12/03/07 11:37 PM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: k9.]
Gary Online   confused
trapper


Registered: 01/08/07
Posts: 8405
Loc: Indiana
yup ... sumtimes they just hang up in there ... wont leave it for sum reason ... lol
_________________________

Top
#443426 - 12/03/07 11:37 PM Re: K-9 trap placement??? [Re: k9.]
Number17 Offline
trapper


Registered: 12/27/06
Posts: 181
Loc: NE Pennsylvania
 Originally Posted By: k9.


I find it interesting that I am percieved as always disagreeing, from the truth,

Well done. However, " I before E except after C " -PERCEIVED- Jonathan, as much as I despise finding fault, is still the "English" king. Other than that it was very well written.
_________________________
Nowadays it just don't pay to be a good 'ol boy.

Top
Page 2 of 3 <123>


Hop to: